Pages

Saturday, 25 April 2015

Protein World's Controversy and Positive Body Image Advertising

'Sex sells' and objectified women is nothing new in advertising- and as a young marketer and a self-proclaimed feminist I am constantly viewing how gender stereotypes affect advertising and the way brands place a certain expectation on how people should behave based on their gender. However I have to say this type of advert doesn't just affect women, I've seen numerous protein shake-type companies flogging their products based on false-idealisms of the perfect man i.e. big muscles, abs etc. and it is really something I feel passionate about that marketers should look at ethically.

Protein World's London Underground adverts have been causing controversy and topical debate across the internet this month. If you haven't seen them here's their 'Beach Body' advert:


There was a huge backlash from angry tweeters and the ads were vandalised:




A petition was started to remove the ads and the ASA received hundreds of complaints. All in all though, the backlash has caused an awesome body positivity message spreaded on the back of putting the Protein World brand in a bad light...



Making people feel bad about their own bodies is not the way to sell products, despite the fact it may have done so 40 years ago, brands have moved on to empowering women, making them feel good about themselves and being accepting. I feel as though the Protein World is so archaic, not adapted to 21st century advertising nor does it consider the affect it may have on the public and the message they are portraying. The media has been shamed for putting unrealistic expectations in the minds of women and men with regard to body image and perceptions, so why hasn't Protein World learnt from other's mistakes? 

If you know me or my tastes in advertising you'll know I often speak about how much I love Dove as an advertiser- their positive body image portraying both women and men gives them such a great brand image and ultimately sell great products! I was so happy to see this piece of newsjacking advertising from Dove:



Hijacking the negative PR which Protein World were receiving was an amazing opportunity for Dove to reinforce their brand values and show themselves completely opposing Protein World's messages. It also helped align Dove with campaigners on social media and showed the brand's support for what they were trying to achieve.

You'd think after receiving such heavy negative publicity and tweets like these:




You'd think the first thing they'd do would be to employ a fantastic PR firm and do some serious crisis management right?

Wrong. 

They handled their social media reaction terribly.

Protein World deleted negative comments from their Facebook page, send horrible automated responses like these:



When they finally decided to respond to criticisms, their responses were rude, inappropriate and all in all made the situation much worse!

This one is significantly disgusting and displays a need to have clear brand guidelines and values to stick by in ALL forms of communication.



This tweet was made by the company CEO who then started blocking all negative tweeters.



Fighting fire with fire is never a good idea- and actually makes the company look guilty- despite no signs of any admittance of such, nor an apology. The brand were retweeting any tweets which shunned campaigners...then the CEO posted this tweet:

And I can't even comment on how greedy, selfish, ignorant and lack of customer focus this brand/ spokesperson is displaying.

And that ladies and gentleman is how not to run an advertising campaign.

However, with the continual push from brands and the media to gain their perception of the 'perfect body', it's unfortunate that people will still buy these crappy products!

Let me know your thoughts over on my twitter account @stefclarkx I would absolutely love to hear your opinions!

Stephy 

Posted by at
Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)